|
# of watchers: 16
|
Fans: 0
| D20: 1 |
| Wiki-page rating | |
| Informative: | 0 |
| Artistic: | 0 |
| Funny-rating: | 0 |
| Friendly: | 0 |


















2007-04-20 [xido]: intriguing.... ;)
2007-06-14 [Cia_mar]: it has been an awfull long time since the good doctor has been here on ET... is there any here that may know if he is ok?
2007-06-14 [dayah]: Where Has Oli Gone? We are all very worried about him.
2007-06-22 [Yncke]: Just for the record: [Dr.Mandarian]'s back. :D
2007-06-22 [dayah]: oh thank you yncke I forgot to say anything in here...heheh yes he is..yay!!
2007-07-06 [xido]: Voting now open:
2007-07-06 [Yncke]: Er, [xido], why don't we wait for [Dr.Mandarian], after all, it is *his* contest. I believe there's still a compass in his mailbox.
2007-07-06 [Estantia]: ah fair point, i'll just leave my voting on the main thing as i did vote on compasses, not for overall best though, and I didn't vote mine.
2007-07-07 [xido]: I know it is his, but as I know that many people have been waiting for quite some time for this, I figured I would put forth some effort to make his job easier.
Also, I incorporated all of the elements of his judging criterion on these polls, so that people can both critique and vote openly. I do not see why we should not vote for our own, as long as we are honest. No one will be harassed for how they vote.
Also, I know how difficult it can be to get a group of people together to judge an event like this. It is nearly impossible in most cases to network people that well. I did some really productive group projects in school where we did that, but everyone knew how to be on the same page, because it was outlined openly on the online school site.
I did not realize that we still had entries that were not posted... Especially since the Contest had been closed.
I for one feel that we have been patient enough, and that the work I have done here will not be too out of line. If anything, I have given Oliver a very good outline of how to poll things like he wanted to have judged by a jury panel.
2007-07-07 [Yncke]: I know you mean well and took a great effort, but well, personally, I'd be quite pissed if someone took hold of a contest I organised while I'm lacking internet access.
Perhaps [Dr.Mandarian] had already a group to vote in mind, and not necessarily Elftowners. ;)
I'm not sure about other entries, but the contest iwasclosed for the maps, the windroses could still come at that time.
Personally, I have contests I've waited for far longer, I think it's more a matter of politeness not to hijack someone's contest without at least asking. Just my opinion.
2007-07-07 [Estantia]: I'm agreeing with Yncke on the politeness thing. it is a very good way of polling (It takes so much into account ^_^) but you do tend to push things at times xido.
2007-07-07 [dayah]: though he might not be back for about three months I believe is what he said..but I agree...he should be the one to give say to if it goes onward...
2007-07-09 [Ocean Soul]: Uhm >> I sent Mandarian a message aeons ago, with the proper scan of my entry, so it's not really fair to have the poll now, with only the crappy photos >> <<
2007-07-11 [Dr.Mandarian]: Heya, I am back now - definately. * wink! * Hm, I am really sorry that I neglected things here like this contest, while I was away... And apologize therefore.
That [xido] took initiative and the further organization of it in his hands does not really anger me. No, in fact I'd rather even be relieved, he did. And the way he designed the public poll for this contest seems well done to me.
So, if every participant of the contest will agree to his administration and the way he designed the poll, I would give it into his responsibility
The only thing that's really not so good would indeed be about [Ocean Soul]'s entry. It is correct, that she sent me the up to date worldmap of hers yet in time, once. And for this map is still in my mailbox, but the poll is already opened and running, this weighs me a bit. Hm, what do you think, [xido]? Could you consider [Ocean Soul]'s entry yet in any way, still?
2007-07-13 [xido]: I appreciate everyone's opinions, but I anticipated [Dr.Mandarian] wanting at least a little bit of help. This was a huge project to take on, and I felt like helping. I am sorry if my direct and proactive stance on helping may have appeared controlling, but I can't help the polls saying that I am the Administrator. This is Oliver's contest, and I am just helping. I will remove my entry from the contest if that is what is necessary to appear formal about it.
For the record, Elftown is a volunteer site, and to volunteer should be looked upon with respect, not impoliteness. Lending a hand can appear one way on the web, even if that was not the intention. I am not going to stop being nice, just so I appear polite. I am polite; crazy, but polite.
I am personally happy to have Oliver back, and welcome any and all input he has on this, now that he is more able.
Also, [Ocean Soul]'s entry was updated on two polls on FMAC_Poll. Everyone should take a look at it once more, in case it changes their mind about its quality. I for one thought it was much more professional looking in full.
Thanks for the word, Oliver. Best wishes,
-will
2007-07-16 [dayah]: ITs great you did xido and its even better to have olivers go on it...I just say its best to always be safe than sorry..:) but Oli mad? kind of hard to beleive he would ever be..*smiles* so a kind person...coudl
2007-11-19 [Dr.Mandarian]: Hey all you cartographers! I just voted for the entries for fantasy maps in: FMAC_poll - and am once more amazed again over what high level of brilliance and calibre they are. So it was kind of a hard task for me to judge them. It is a pleasure to have such manies of high quality artworks gathered here. I once again have to thank all who participated in this! And I also want to express again, in this place, how sorry I am that the whole process of the running contest has been so unfortunately interrupted for so long, due to my absence - and kind of dragged along then. I assure you that it has got nothing to do with a lack of interest in this, to any time. I just first have been forced by personal circumstances to not be able to get online for a pretty long while. And after I returned to town, I missed energy and time enough, to dedicate myself more to the outturn of the contest procedure here.
I hope that you are not badly disappointed about that.
Still I wanted to ask you all, if you'd like to finish this contest soon, after all, or if you'd maybe like me to first yet care a bit for advertising the poll more over the next days - as for example trying to apply for a main street place for it? I don't know exactly, what [xido] planned for the further scope of the contest end, but I will in any case contact him soon and discuss with him, about the evaluation of the poll he kindly created, and the finish of the whole contest. Having a winner in each category and a badge for each winner then, how I hope.
2007-11-19 [Yncke]: I agree that it could use a bit more votes. :)
2007-11-19 [Dr.Mandarian]: Yes, I think the contest actually absolutely deserves to become known by a broader public, yet, before it closes with a winner. As long as the contestants here haven't lost the enthusiasm for it already. Which would be a pity. I might write to the main street poll responsibles and try to bring it there.
2008-03-18 [Dr.Mandarian]:
2008-03-19 [xido]: Great job, everyone. A lot of really amazing talent here. ;)
-will
Number of comments: 272
| Show these comments on your site |